I say let them go. If you want to play Santa.offer them for free on the boards or eBay. You'll probably make some old timer's day that still uses that CD Player.
I'm sure you've seen our saved post at the top of the forums to one of the top sharers through the years to our community, Neil left me his entire collection of DVD.s, probably the largest collection of all time. They were all digitized and given to Monmouth University for their collection of Bruce's music.
I realize it feels like you are giving away a part of your soul, all those years of shopping and trading for them. It's like giving away memories. But now their taking up space and you'll never listen to them again. If you have notes on them, add the notes to the digital copy either a .jpg or a word doc.
Anyway that's my 2 cents.